Helen McEntee

Overall sentiment: 0.10
Back to Debate

I move: (1) THAT the rate of value-added tax chargeable on the supply of electricity provided for by section 46(1)(caa) of, and paragraph 17(2) of Schedule 3 to, the Value-Added Tax Consolidation Act 2010 (No. 31 of 2010) and the supply of gas provided for by section 46(1)(caa) of, and paragraph 17(3) of Schedule 3 to, that Act, being 9 per cent until 31 October 2025, be extended until 31 December 2030 and that section 46(1)(caa) of that Act be amended accordingly. (2) THAT this Resolution shall have effect on and from 8 October 2025. (3) IT is hereby declared that it is expedient in the public interest that this Resolution shall have statutory effect under the provisions of the Provisional Collection of Taxes Act 1927 (No. 7 of 1927). This resolution provides for an extension in the temporary reduction in VAT on gas and electricity at an estimated cost of €254 million per year. At present, gas and electricity have a 9% VAT rate applied on a temporary basis until 31 October this year. This rate is due to revert to 13.5% from 1 November. This temporary reduction, introduced in May 2022, was one of the Government's responses to the current energy crisis and its impact on the cost of living. While inflation has eased and global energy prices have dropped, I believe it is appropriate to provide an extension to this measure. For many people, the cost of living remains relatively high, so the Government is proposing this extension from 1 November this year until the end of 2030. The cumulative cost of the measure since its introduction is estimated to be €746 million. As Deputies will recall, the background to this measure is that up to April 2022, Ireland maintained a historical derogation in respect of VAT rate on gas and electricity of 13.5%. This derogation was necessary as, otherwise, the standard rate of VAT of 23% would have applied. However, following the amendment to annexe III of the VAT directive in 2022, it was expanded to include gas and electricity. This meant that Ireland could apply a reduced rate of 9% to these products in line with other goods and services to which a reduced rate applies and that is exactly what we are doing here for the next five years.

Sentiment score: 0.06

I thank the Deputies. This financial resolution provides for the reduction of the VAT rate applied to the sale of new apartments to 9% from 8 October 2025. It will apply to the 31 December 2030, that is, for the next five years. Its estimated cost for the first year is €250 million. The Government is committed to the delivery of more than 300,000 new homes by 2023. It is, of course, apparent that apartments need to be a significant part of that delivery. This is about ensuring that we have a greater delivery of not just apartments but cost-rental, affordable and private homes. To say that nothing is being spent or that there has been no focus on housing in this budget other than this specific measure simply is not correct. I will outline matters again. There is an allocation of €11.3 billion to the Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage for 2026. A total of €7.2 billion of that allocation is in capital funding, which will include €2.9 billion to support the delivery of thousands of new build social homes and second-hand acquisitions; €1.2 billion for the starter homes programme to deliver thousands of starter homes through a range of affordability supports, alongside the help-to-buy initiative; €300 million to support the regeneration of our towns and urban areas through the urban regeneration development fund; €205 million for a new housing activation infrastructure fund to support the work of the new housing activation office; €140 million to retrofit further homes; and €130 million to fund up to 17,000 grants to adapt the homes of older people and people with disabilities, which is in addition to the significant €628 million increase in disability funding this year. On top of those measures, there is then €2 billion to support 100,000 households through the existing different schemes, such as the rental accommodation and social housing current expenditure schemes. It is important to continue those schemes. We need to increase our focus on building apartment complexes. A total of 50% of our employment or growth is going to happen across five cities, namely, Dublin, Cork, Waterford, Limerick and Galway. A total of 40% of our development will happen in brownfield sites in the coming years. We need to ensure that we are doing more when it comes to apartment complexes. Construction in this area is not moving so we have to ensure we are putting in place measures that will actually move and ensure we have delivery. Looking solely at Dublin, of the last 44,500 units with planning permission, 90% of those, or approximately 40,000, are apartments that have not yet commenced. Overall, some 70,000 apartments with planning permission have not gone anywhere. That is not just in the past five or six months. Rather, it goes back as far as 2022 and before. We need to ensure that we are doing – and this is just one measure – what we can to activate. It is very clear there is a viability gap between apartments and houses in Ireland. That is something that has been said time and again. The purpose of this measure, therefore, is to reduce that gap to achieve wider policy goals as we have outlined, many of which are the national planning framework, such as increasing density and recognising demographic and societal changes. All of this can be delivered through more housing and apartment delivery. In terms of the guidelines and how they will be implemented, Revenue is working to develop and implement the different guidelines. Essentially, this is aimed at incentivising builders to build additional apartments. This will stretch over a number of different years. With regard to the types of apartments, this measure will apply where a property is at least two storeys high and has least three units. It will not extend to duplexes or single-storey developments. It will extend to student accommodation as long as it meets the criteria for apartments, that is, multistorey accommodation with at least three units. It will not apply to apartments built over a business or apartments constructed as part of a hotel. Overall, it will fall within the definition from high-value accommodation to apartments built for social housing purposes and will cover all sizes of apartments. All the detail is being worked through. The guidelines to implement this are being developed by Revenue. This can be applied to by and can be sold on to any individual or group, be it a housing body, private or otherwise. This is about making sure we construct more apartments. In the past number of years, that has not been happening. There is a viability gap there and the aim behind this is to address it. It is one measure among a number we are introducing to increase the overall construction of affordable, social and private apartments and homes for people across the country.

Sentiment score: 0.14

To respond to a number of points, I have never seen a Government implement in full its programme for Government in one year. Deputies need to acknowledge that we have four years hopefully ahead of us to implement many more measures-----

Sentiment score: 0.24

-----and to activate more housing nor have I ever seen a Government that was not allowed to do more than the programme for Government. We may stray beyond the programme for Government from time to time, so be warned. Meath County Council has surpassed its housing targets with the support of Government. We will work with it to do even more. Coming from a county with a growing young population, just like the Deputy, I want to ensure that constituents have access to affordable homes and that they can buy, rent and own. On the timelines, the advice that I have been given is that there were legal issues around the overall timeline, but also the potential implications to stall the markets. If we set a future date, whether it is tomorrow or in six months, the further out it is we prevent the commencement of property. There were legal issues around defining the commencement date and the timing. That is the information I have been given. This is on top of any of the other measures that have been put in place. I have to stress again that this about activating the tens of thousands of planning permissions that have not yet started and have not yet been acted on and making sure that we can bring far more apartment complexes into the overall context for people.

Sentiment score: 0.07

I have answered it. It is in addition to any other schemes.

Sentiment score: 0.00